>Should they stay or should they go?

>There’s a chance that by the start of next season, Cobblers fans will be watching an entirely new side with no less than eleven players out on contract in the summer. Sammo has indicated that most will be playing for their futures at the club over the next few weeks so who should we offer new deals to and who are surplus to requirements? Unfortunately looking at the list shows that most are big players and with the likes of Josh Walker and Ben Tozer ending their loan spells come May it’ll be a nervy time to be a Town fan!

Here’s my views on the guys out of contract:

Chris Dunn…tough one fro Dunny. He’s not entirely consistent but can pull off some moments of quality on his day. Having come through the youth system behind Mark Bunn he’s not hit the same levels but has kept us in one or two games. Is that enough though? Personally I think it could be time to look into other options and for a keeper wanting first team football it could mean the end of the road and a fresh challenge. VERDICT: Let go

Abdul Osman…we’ve all seen how much we miss Osman in the last couple of games so he’s one we need to tie down. Sammo will be desperate to keep his spine in tact and Osman is a key part of that. VERDICT: Keep

Liam Davis…Davis has been attracting scouts from sides at a higher level but hasn’t seemed to get a really good run in the side for various reasons this term. Given a full pre-season and a good formation that we stick to though and he can still have a major role to play. Verdict: Keep

Craig Hinton…out on loan at the moment with his highlight for the Cobblers this season being his fantastic camera and interview skills on the Liverpool “Behind the Scenes” videos that appeared on the official website post match! Seems a good character for the dressing room but is that enough with wages needing to be freed up? Sorry Craig! Verdict: Get rid

Billy McKay…Another tough one. Billy gives everything to his game and doesn’t get the plaudits a lot of the time. I still feel he has a lot to give to us and not just as a substitute to Leon and Harrad for his menacing of defenders and decent goal scoring touch. Verdict: Keep

Leon McKenzie…The goal ratio speaks for itself and we have to just hope that Leon is settled and wants to stick around. A promising partnership with Shaun Harrad is already forming and when both fit and one their form could be one of the best partnerships in the league. Verdict: Keep

Kevin Thornton…Ah, the enigma that is! In and out of the side this season and a real luxury when he’s on his game. Thornton was tipped to be the star of the season but injuries have been cruel to the former Coventry man. Still, Sammo seems to have turned him around and there’s no doubt that we need to keep hold. Verdict: Keep

Marcus Hall…Brought in as a quick fire replacement for Peter Gilbert, Hall has been as consistent as his predecessor at left back. Should stay, and I don’t see any reason why he won’t. Verdict: Keep

Francis Laurent…I’ve not actually seen Laurent play yet but he’s another who appears to need his fitness back before he can get going. Hence the problem with mid-season deals like this one where the player isn’t 100% and always playing catch up. It would only be down to the players’ attitude to his return to form that would be needed to get Sammo on board for a longer deal. Verdict: A tentative Keep

Paul Rodgers…With John Johnson coming in it’s been tough for Rodgers to break into the first team squad but he’s certainly a player that can be useful in many positions so for that reason alone we should hold on to him. Verdict: Keep

Dean Beckwith…Not the quickest of defenders and one prone to the odd error but he’s formed a good partnership with Ben Tozer. Assuming Tozer doesn’t come back we will need Beckwith in tact for continuity. Verdict: Keep

So basically I’m keeping nine out of eleven based on where we are at the moment and assuming that there’s not going to be a miraculous playoff chasing end to the season. Let me know your thoughts either way! Continuity is needed as mentioned but attitudes, discipline and the like are also required so that we can show the undoubted quality that this side has.

2 thoughts on “>Should they stay or should they go?

  1. >Hello Danny, me again I'm afraid! Another interesting article, and particularly timely in light of the managers recent comments. I'd pretty much agree with all your acertations, with one or two minor caveats and exceptions. With Dunn, it is very interesting to see how the crowd sometimes react negatively to him, but overall I'd say he wins more points than he loses. He's also young, by goalkeeping standards, and should get better. I have only seen Dunn and Steele in the Northampton goal and it is perhaps unfair to oompare the two, as Steele may well play in the Priemership sooner rather than later. Are Northampton likely to attract a better keeper than Dunn at the moment? I'm not so sure.Like you, I also like Mckay and think he can continue to improve with the right partner.He won't, however, in his current role alongside a partner of similar height etc. Although not ideal, I think Mckay and Holt has been the most effective partnership up front this season and am not so optimistic about Harrad and Mckenzie as a duo. The club also need to look very closely at how the latters knee is going to withstand a full season, even after a decent pre-season. I was really loooking forward to seeing Purcell play and was worried for him and the club when he got so badly injured. For me an interesting one is Gilligan. Again, for some reason, not popular with the crowd, but at a young age has played a lot of games for the club and, in my humble opinion, generally does well. He also scored a lot of goals last year. He played through the pain barrier earlier in the season when the team needed him. I suspected something was up when he failed to make the bench for the Crewe (?)game, but was still surprised when he went on loan to Torquay. What will happen with him in the summer.I like Rodgers and think he should have been played more on the right-side of midfield this season. Laurent? Have seen, and whilst not wishing to judge him too quickly, he hasn't impressed me thus far.The problem Cobblers might have is retaining players that have done well, but could play at a higher level – Osman in particular is vital to the team, and along with Holt has been superb this season. Again, a view from a 'Johnny come lately'.Joe

  2. >Hello there! Comments always welcome, at least I know someone's reading!Gilligan is another interesting one indeed. I've never really understood what a section of the crowd has against him. For the amount of appearances he's put in most players would be held in a very high regard! Hopefully he'll come back from his loan and fight for his place again. Strange to think that we signed him as a striker initially!McKenzie's injury problems are frustrating but I'm not completely sure whether it's expected to be continuous or whether a pre season would see him get fully fit again. I guess that's a big call for Sammo in terms of wages.Can see your point re: Dunn but was thinking about the player more than anything. I hope he proves me wrong but if we're talking about being promotion challenges we've always had a top keeper (Woody, Welch, Bunn, Harper) which I don't think Dunn is (just yet anyway). Hopefully it's more than the contracts they're playing for come the end of the season anyway!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s